EVU XXVII 2018 – 11 Evaluation of dash cams as proof of fraudulent loss events
Evaluation of dash cams
as proof of fraudulent loss events
Dr. Michael Weyde, Dipl.-Ing. Björn Kurzke
Priester & Weyde
Generally speaking it is not possible to provide unequivocal proof of fraudulent damage claims. Yet, other than EDR, video images from dash cams lend themselves to reconstructing the driving behaviour of the parties involved in an accident with such accuracy that when carefully appraising all the evidence it is possible consistently to deduce whether a collision has been caused deliberately.
The opportunities a!orded by video evaluation are, however, limited when the frame rate is too low and/or the image resolution is insu”cient. Yet some modern dash cams have full HD mode which, as a rule, provides su”ciently high image quality and resolution during daylight hours to allow evaluation. During the hours of darkness accident reconstruction is, however, limited due to a lack of detailed reference points. Furthermore frame rates of below 10 fps do not allow detailed evaluation of dynamic behaviour during road tra”c accidents. Frame rates of at least around 30 fps are needed for a su”cient chronological and geographical analysis of the movements of the vehicles other than the vehicle equipped with a dash cam depicted in the video as well as the movements of the dash cam vehicle itself provided there are su”cient reference points at the concrete locality. In such cases, and based on
traditional accident prevention considerations, it might well be possible to di!erentiate between driving behaviour typical for trying to avoid the accident and driving behaviour typical for intentionally causing an accident. From a technical point of view typical for intentionally caused accidents is not the mere lack of a suitable avoidance strategy but the interruption of the initial avoidance strategy particularly if it was only such an interruption which allowed for the collision to happen.
La lettura di questo articolo è riservata ai soli Soci EVU Italia.
|Dr. Michael Weyde, Dipl.-Ing. Björn Kurzke Priester & Weyde